Years 4 to 5 of the MBChB

Dr. Owen Dempsey

Year 5 Lead

Dr. Craig Brown

Deputy Lead Year 5

Topics:

  • Why Year 5 is really an “apprenticeship year”
  • The role of simulation in building confidence and clinical reasoning
  • How OSCEs and patient partners shape assessment
  • Practical tips for NHS clinicians supervising students
  • The power of feedback and culture in creating confident graduates

The final years of medical school aren’t just about passing exams, they’re about transitioning into professional practice. In this podcast, Craig Brown (Deputy Lead for Year 5) and Owen Dempsey (Year 5 Lead) discuss what makes Years 4 and 5 so important for developing safe, confident, and capable doctors.


Year 5: The Apprenticeship Year

By Year 5, Aberdeen medical students have already cleared their major knowledge-based exams. Now, the focus shifts to acting as doctors-in-waiting: shadowing junior doctors, managing patients under supervision, and working within ward teams. It’s an apprenticeship model, giving students responsibility in a safe, structured environment.

Students also take part in assistantships, mandated by the GMC, where they manage a small group of patients with close oversight. This helps them mature clinically and prepares them for the leap into Foundation training.


Simulation and Safe Learning

Simulation plays a key role in pushing students to the edge of their comfort zones. Through realistic scenarios, followed by structured learning conversations, students practice decision-making, communication, and managing uncertainty. It’s not just about “knowing the right answer,” but about thinking and acting like a doctor.


Assessment and OSCEs

While finals are technically done in Year 4, Year 5 isn’t assessment-free. Students face gruelling OSCEs, testing their ability to manage complex clinical scenarios. These require massive coordination: dozens of examiners, patient partners, and support staff. Clinicians from across the NHS are encouraged to get involved, whether through examining, simulation, or even writing new exam questions.


The Role of Clinicians

Craig and Owen highlight the vital role of NHS clinicians in teaching and assessment. From supervising students on the wards to offering constructive feedback, everyday interactions shape how confident and capable students feel. Even a simple “well done” can have a huge impact.

They also stress the importance of feedback and culture, creating environments where students feel safe to admit uncertainty, ask questions, and learn from mistakes. Visibility helps too: Aberdeen’s black-scrub uniforms ensure students stand out on wards, making it easier for clinicians to bring them into real learning moments.


Beyond 9–5

Students also learn about the realities of night shifts and out-of-hours care. Hospitals are very different places at 2 a.m., and preparing students for that environment ensures they are ready for the demands of real clinical life.


Takeaway

Years 4 and 5 mark the final transformation from student to doctor. With simulation, real-world placements, and supportive supervision, students gain the skills, confidence, and professional maturity they need to thrive in the NHS.

And for clinicians? There are many ways to get involved, examining OSCEs, volunteering in simulation, writing questions, or simply welcoming students onto your ward.